Should the Government Be Investigating… the Government?
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is currently consulting on whether the Government’s use of the term ‘free childcare’ could be misleading to parents.
On the surface, that sounds like a positive step. But it raises an uncomfortable question…
How independent can an investigation really be when the organisation investigating is itself a government body?
For years, childcare providers and parents have raised concerns that the ‘free childcare’ campaign doesn’t reflect the reality they experience. Many providers say government funding falls well below the true cost of delivering high-quality early education, leaving them with little choice but to charge for additional services or restrict funded places.
Those concerns haven’t come from a handful of isolated settings. They have been raised repeatedly across the sector by nurseries, childminders, representative groups and campaigners.
Now, rather than an independent external investigation, the consultation is being led by the CMA – a non-ministerial government department sponsored by the Department for Business and Trade. While the CMA operates independently in its decision-making, it remains part of the wider public sector.
That leaves many asking whether the Government objectively investigate a campaign that it created?
Will providers and parents have confidence in the outcome?
Would an entirely independent review inspire greater public trust?
These aren’t accusations. They’re questions about transparency, accountability and public confidence.
The consultation is still an important opportunity. The more evidence providers and parents submit, the harder it becomes to ignore the lived reality behind the words ‘free childcare’.
Whatever your view, one thing is clear.
Families deserve honest information. Providers deserve funding that reflects the real cost of care. And the public deserves confidence that concerns about government advertising are examined fairly and transparently.
What do you think? Should the Government be investigating its own ‘free childcare’ campaign, or should an independent body lead the review?
Underfunding childcare is not just a policy choice; it is a decision that directly harms the workforce delivering it.
I have been following someone called ‘The Nursery Survivor’ on Instagram. The account is run by an ex-nursery worker who clearly had some terrible experiences working in nurseries. The short videos are funny and sometimes excruciatingly accurate. She portrays life in...
Britain Is Getting Childcare Wrong – And Our Children Will Pay the Price
Across the world, governments are scrambling to solve a childcare crisis. Costs are soaring, parents are struggling, women are being pushed out of work, and birth rates are falling. In response, politicians are promising ‘free childcare’ at an unprecedented scale. On...
An open letter to parents about “Free” Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC)
Dear parents, We are writing to explain what is happening behind the scenes in Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) right now, and why many nurseries are deeply worried about the future of ECEC places and whether early years education and childcare will still...
Failing at work to win at motherhood
Recently, a GP in England was suspended for five months after falsifying patient appointments so she could leave on time to pick up her children. Dr Helen Eisenhauer, a mother of two working in Nottingham, had already seen the patients by phone earlier in the day but...
A Year of Voices, Visibility, and Change: What We’ve Achieved Together
As this year comes to a close, we wanted to take a moment to reflect on what we’ve achieved as a campaign and more importantly, ‘why’ we’re here in the first place. Free Childcare UK was created out of necessity. Not as a political slogan or a headline-grabbing...
The Hidden Costs of Childcare: What Government Funding Doesn’t Cover
The UK government funds early years childcare through the Early Years National Funding Formula (EYNFF), which sets hourly funding rates paid to local authorities and then passed to nurseries. These rates vary by age group and area, and they are often presented as the...
When Safeguarding Fails: What the Nursery Most Recent Abuse Scandal Reveals About Our Early Years System
The recent revelations about a sexual predator operating within English nurseries have shaken the early years sector and the wider public. Cases like this are shocking not only because of the profound harm caused to vulnerable children, but because they expose a...
Thinking of Reporting a Childcare Setting to Ofsted? What Parents Should Know First
In early years, everyone - parents, practitioners, managers, and Ofsted - share the same priority: children’s safety, happiness, and wellbeing. When something worries you about your child’s nursery, preschool or childminder, you absolutely have the right to raise it....
The Christmas Crunch: How ‘Free’ Childcare Leaves Parents Struggling During the Most Expensive Time of Year
For many families, Christmas is meant to be a season of joy - twinkling lights, excited children, and time together. But for parents relying on so-called ‘free childcare’, December often brings a very different reality: rising costs, stretched finances, and the hard...
Autumn Budget 2025: What is the Next Government Must Fix in Childcare
As the UK heads toward another major election cycle and the next round of budget decisions, one issue keeps rising to the top of national conversations. Childcare. It is often framed as a family issue, yet the reality is far more serious.It is an economic emergency, a...