Should the Government Be Investigating… the Government?
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is currently consulting on whether the Government’s use of the term ‘free childcare’ could be misleading to parents.
On the surface, that sounds like a positive step. But it raises an uncomfortable question…
How independent can an investigation really be when the organisation investigating is itself a government body?
For years, childcare providers and parents have raised concerns that the ‘free childcare’ campaign doesn’t reflect the reality they experience. Many providers say government funding falls well below the true cost of delivering high-quality early education, leaving them with little choice but to charge for additional services or restrict funded places.
Those concerns haven’t come from a handful of isolated settings. They have been raised repeatedly across the sector by nurseries, childminders, representative groups and campaigners.
Now, rather than an independent external investigation, the consultation is being led by the CMA – a non-ministerial government department sponsored by the Department for Business and Trade. While the CMA operates independently in its decision-making, it remains part of the wider public sector.
That leaves many asking whether the Government objectively investigate a campaign that it created?
Will providers and parents have confidence in the outcome?
Would an entirely independent review inspire greater public trust?
These aren’t accusations. They’re questions about transparency, accountability and public confidence.
The consultation is still an important opportunity. The more evidence providers and parents submit, the harder it becomes to ignore the lived reality behind the words ‘free childcare’.
Whatever your view, one thing is clear.
Families deserve honest information. Providers deserve funding that reflects the real cost of care. And the public deserves confidence that concerns about government advertising are examined fairly and transparently.
What do you think? Should the Government be investigating its own ‘free childcare’ campaign, or should an independent body lead the review?
An Open Letter to the Department for Education and Olivia Bailey MP
Dear Minister, We write to you as a campaign group representative of the independent early years sector; providers who, for decades, have formed the backbone of early education and childcare across the UK. We are compelled to ask a simple but urgent question: How much...
30 Hours Free Childcare from 9 Months: Why It’s So Confusing for Parents
The government now offers funded childcare for children from 9 months old, but many parents are finding the system confusing, especially when maternity leave and term dates come into play. If you’re planning your return to work, it’s important to understand when you...
Understanding the 30 Hours Free Childcare Funding in the UK
The UK’s 30 hours free childcare funding can be incredibly helpful for working families but it can also feel confusing. Many parents are surprised by the rules, deadlines, and eligibility checks involved. Here are some of the most common questions parents ask about...
What “Free Childcare” Really Means: Why Care Costs What It Costs
When people hear the phrase “free childcare”, it sounds like a simple solution for families struggling with rising costs.But behind the headline is a more complex reality, one that many parents, policymakers and the public don’t always see.One way to understand it is...
Why humans take so long to grow up – and why that matters
If you’ve ever watched a foal stand within an hour of birth or a puppy tumble confidently about within weeks, it’s hard not to wonder: why do humans take so long to grow up? The short answer is evolution. The longer answer is far more interesting. Humans are born...
A provider’s response to the Mother & Baby article.
This article was sent to FCUKTUS by an nursery owner after reading the Mother and baby Article published on 10 February. The author wishes to remain anonymous. The recent article in Mother and Baby by Hannah Carroll about nursery...
Two Tiers of Nursery Inspection? Why Parents Should Be Asking Hard Questions About School-Based Nurseries
The Government’s rapid expansion of school-based nurseries is being framed as a solution to the childcare crisis - more places, more convenience and more support for working families. For many parents, that sounds like a long-awaited step forward. But beneath the...
The Deaf Ears of the DfE
Early years providers are being placed in an impossible position. The sector is under intense regulatory pressure from Ofsted to deliver inclusion and accessibility for all children, including those with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities. At the same time,...
The Future of Independent Nurseries in the UK: Consolidation, Pressure and What Comes Next
Independent nurseries in the UK are at a crossroads. Over the past few years, large nursery groups and private equity–backed operators have been steadily buying up single-site and small-group providers. This isn’t accidental, it’s structural. And it raises an...
Why Itemised Invoices Risk Breaking Early Years Provision
The government’s push for early years providers to itemise invoices is presented as a move towards transparency and parental choice. In practice, it risks undermining how nurseries actually function. Nursery fees are not a collection of optional extras. They are the...